Throw Food For Animals has shot to the top of Roblox’s trending charts, and it is easy to see why. You train your strength, throw food as far as you can, and catch the animals that come running to collect it. Every animal you place on your plot earns money every second, so the animals you choose decide how fast you progress.
With 164 animals in the Index after Update 3, plus egg and shop animals that copy your best earner’s income, it can be hard to know which ones are worth a slot. This Throw Food For Animals tier list ranks the animals by how much money they make and how long they stay useful, so you know what to chase next.
Quick answer: The best animal in Throw Food For Animals is the Pumpkin Monster, whose x9 multiplier scales with your best animal, followed by the Waste Harvester, the highest-earning catchable animal at $410Dd per second. The Reaper and Meltdown Idol round out the top picks.
Last Updated: November 20, 2026 (Update 3)
Throw Food For Animals Tier List
We ranked animals by base income per second and by how long they stay useful as you unlock new zones. Egg and shop animals are ranked by their income multiplier, since they earn a multiple of your best animal rather than a fixed amount.
| S | Pumpkin MonsterReaperWaste HarvesterMeltdown IdolRad ScarecrowFerro Wyrm |
|---|---|
| A | Giant SquidReaper SteedIsotope AngelGlassback ColossusSiren SpireOther Nuclear Wasteland animalsGhost PirateLichGhostly Horse |
| B | DemonPhantom Harbor animalsHeadless HorsemanHarvest Fields animalsNightmareShadow Realm animals |
| C | Woolly MammothSkeleton HorseMythical Paradise animalsAncient Ruins animalsHell animals |
| D | SkeletonDeep Waters animalsPrehistoric Forest animalsWinter animalsTaiga and earlier zones |
This list reflects Update 3 (New Regions, early November 2026) and the Dreamland event. The 24 animals from the new Cursed Carnival and Eclipse Kingdom zones are not ranked yet because their income has not been documented. Expect them to sit at the top once it is, and expect rankings to change with each update.
Best Animals by Income
Base income is the money an animal earns per second before mutations and size bonuses. Only animals placed in your 20 plot slots earn money.
| Animal | Rarity | Zone / Source | Income |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pumpkin Monster | Divine | Halloween Egg (1%) or 499 Robux | x9 your best animal |
| Reaper | Celestial | Halloween Egg (4%) | x5 your best animal |
| Giant Squid | Celestial | 299 Robux | x3 your best animal |
| Reaper Steed | Mythic | Halloween Egg (10%) | x3 your best animal |
| Waste Harvester | Supreme | Nuclear Wasteland | $410Dd/s |
| Meltdown Idol | Supreme | Nuclear Wasteland | $205Dd/s |
| Rad Scarecrow | Cosmic | Nuclear Wasteland | $102Dd/s |
| Ferro Wyrm | Cosmic | Nuclear Wasteland | $51.2Dd/s |
| Isotope Angel | Eternal | Nuclear Wasteland | $25.6Dd/s |
| Glassback Colossus | Eternal | Nuclear Wasteland | $12.8Dd/s |
| Siren Spire | Eternal | Nuclear Wasteland | $6.4Dd/s |
| Ghost Pirate | Cosmic | Phantom Harbor | $256Dc/s |
| Lich | Eternal | Phantom Harbor | $128Dc/s |
| Ghostly Horse | Eternal | Phantom Harbor | $64Dc/s |
| Headless Horseman | Eternal | Harvest Fields | $3.2No/s |
| Nightmare | Eternal | Shadow Realm | $32Sp/s |
| Phoenix | Celestial | Mythical Paradise | $380Qi/s |
| Hydra | Celestial | Ancient Ruins | $10Qi/s |
| Cerberus | Divine | Hell | $250Qa/s |
S Tier – Best Animals in Throw Food For Animals
Pumpkin Monster
The Pumpkin Monster earns nine times the income of your best animal, so it never goes out of date: every time you catch a better animal, the Pumpkin Monster gets better too. It was a 1% drop from the Halloween Egg and can also be bought for 499 Robux. The Halloween event ended on November 1, so the Robux option is the reliable way to get it.
Reaper
The Reaper copies your best animal’s income five times over, which makes it the second-best scaling animal in the game. It came from the Halloween Egg at a 4% chance. If you already own one, keep it in a slot permanently.
Waste Harvester
The Waste Harvester is the highest-earning catchable animal, at $410Dd per second, and it can be sold for $8.2Td. It lives in the Nuclear Wasteland, which needs a throw of around 6,200 studs, and you need Uranium Cake to attract it, so it is strictly an endgame target.
Meltdown Idol
The second Supreme animal in the Nuclear Wasteland earns exactly half of the Waste Harvester’s income. It shares the same zone and food requirement and is just as worth a slot.
Rad Scarecrow and Ferro Wyrm
These two Cosmic animals are the next best earners in the Nuclear Wasteland, at a quarter and an eighth of the Waste Harvester’s income. They are easier to land than the Supreme pair and still outearn everything outside the zone.
A Tier – Excellent Late-Game Animals
Giant Squid
A 299 Robux shop animal that earns three times your best animal’s income. It is one of the best Robux purchases because, like the Pumpkin Monster, it keeps scaling as you progress.
Reaper Steed
A Mythic Halloween Egg animal (10% chance) with the same x3 multiplier as the Giant Squid. Whether the Halloween Egg can still be opened has not been confirmed, so treat it as a keeper if you already own it.
Isotope Angel, Glassback Colossus, Siren Spire and the rest of Nuclear Wasteland
Even the weakest Nuclear Wasteland animal outearns everything in Phantom Harbor, so this zone is the best place to fill all 20 of your slots. The three Eternal animals here earn between $6.4Dd and $25.6Dd per second.
Ghost Pirate, Lich and Ghostly Horse
These are the best animals in Phantom Harbor, the strongest zone below the Nuclear Wasteland at roughly level 1,000. Ghost Pirate tops the zone at $256Dc per second, and Phantom Lobster is the food that pulls the rarest animals here. All three get replaced once you reach the Nuclear Wasteland.
B Tier – Strong Mid-Game Animals
Demon
A Legendary Halloween Egg animal (17% chance) that doubles your best animal’s income. It is weaker than the other multiplier animals but still worth keeping in a slot.
Phantom Harbor animals
The rest of Phantom Harbor, from Ghost to Banshee, is a solid upgrade path around level 1,000 before you push into the Nuclear Wasteland.
Headless Horseman and Harvest Fields
Headless Horseman is the best Harvest Fields animal at $3.2No per second, alongside the Pumpkin Golem. Use Golden Pumpkin to target them, then move on once you reach Phantom Harbor.
Nightmare and Shadow Realm
Nightmare tops the Shadow Realm at $32Sp per second. This zone is a good mid-game stop around level 640, but it is quickly outscaled.
C Tier – Stepping Stones
Woolly Mammoth and Skeleton Horse
Both earn 1.5 times your best animal. The Woolly Mammoth costs 199 Robux, which is poor value next to the Giant Squid’s x3 for 299 Robux. The Skeleton Horse came from the Halloween Egg (28% chance).
Mythical Paradise, Ancient Ruins and Hell
Phoenix ($380Qi/s), Hydra ($10Qi/s) and Cerberus ($250Qa/s) are useful stepping stones between levels 400 and 550. Their high rarity does not save them from being outscaled by the zones that follow. Sundae Tower is the best food for Mythical Paradise.
D Tier – Early Game Animals
Skeleton
The Skeleton’s x1 multiplier simply duplicates your best animal’s income. It is better than an empty slot, but every other multiplier animal beats it.
Deep Waters, Prehistoric Forest and Winter
These zones earn in the trillions to quadrillions per second. Plesiosaur ($6.2Qa/s) and Sabertooth Tiger ($3.8T/s) are worth keeping for a short while, but you will replace them as soon as you reach Hell.
Taiga and earlier zones
Forest, Savanna, Desert, Jungle, Ocean, Mountains and Taiga are where every run starts. Good early targets are Pony, Lion, Kangaroo, Gorilla, Seal, Griffin and Fenrir, but all of them should be swapped out once you reach Winter.
Best Animals for Beginners
- Push strength first: each pull-up bar level adds throw distance, which is what unlocks new zones.
- Use the last food of each zone: it targets that zone’s rarest animals.
- Early path: Pony, then Lion, Kangaroo and Gorilla as your throw distance grows.
- Hit Equip Best often: it fills your 20 slots with your top earners automatically.
- Cheapest boost: the x2 Cash game pass costs 99 Robux. The x2 Training Power pass costs 149 Robux.
See our Throw Food For Animals Food Index for every food, tier and price.
What Changed in Update 3 and the Dreamland Event
- Update 3 (New Regions): added the Cursed Carnival and Eclipse Kingdom zones with 12 animals each, new Tier 18 and Tier 19 foods, new training bars and a higher strength cap.
- Dreamland event (from November 14): zones rotate into Dreamland habitats every 30 minutes with 24 limited animals. Collecting all of them rewards the Dream Dragon. Dream Potions cost 350 Research Tokens each and add a 25% infusion chance.
- Coming next: a Thanksgiving event is scheduled for November 21–22.
For more on the latest map, read our Throw Food For Animals new map guide.
FAQ
What is the best animal in Throw Food For Animals?
The Pumpkin Monster is the best overall because its x9 multiplier scales with your best animal. The Waste Harvester is the best animal you can catch, earning $410Dd per second.
What is the best Robux purchase in Throw Food For Animals?
The Pumpkin Monster (499 Robux) offers the biggest multiplier, while the Giant Squid (299 Robux) is the best value. For a cheaper boost, the x2 Cash pass costs 99 Robux.
Are the Cursed Carnival and Eclipse Kingdom animals better?
They are the newest zones from Update 3, so they are likely to earn more than earlier zones, but their income has not been documented yet. We will rank them once it is.
How do I catch rarer animals?
Train your strength to throw farther, unlock the next zone, and use the best food for that zone. The last food made for each zone targets its rarest animals.
More Roblox guides: Throw Food For Animals Food Index | Grow a Garden Pet Tier List | Break and Steal an Egg Tier List | All Roblox Game Codes

Hi, I’m Ankit Kumar, the founder of StealthyGaming. I handle everything from SEO to researching and writing gaming articles. I’m passionate about helping fellow gamers stay updated with the latest tips, guides, and news. When I’m not optimizing content, I’m probably testing out new games or digging into strategies to make my articles as helpful and engaging as possible.
Rankings reflect the current update and are rechecked after balance patches. How we research and verify our guides.